Defective Tire Lawsuits: Holding Manufacturers and Distributors Accountable
Defective tires have caused countless preventable tragedies on American roads, leading to wrongful death claims, catastrophic injuries, and long legal battles. One case that stands out is a settled wrongful death lawsuit against the Denman Tire Corporation, in which the plaintiffs also named the tire distributor and the tire dealer as co-defendants. The court ultimately ruled in favor of the plaintiffs, who lost their four-year-old daughter due to a defective tire installed on a Chevy Blazer.
The Fatal Accident
The Chevy Blazer involved in this tragedy was a used vehicle purchased by its current owner two years before the accident. The previous owner had replaced the original tires with three-foot-tall "monster" tires, raising the vehicle’s center of gravity by approximately nine inches. This modification made the SUV inherently unstable and unsafe for city streets, especially at higher speeds or during abrupt maneuvers.
Evidence presented in court revealed that the distributor had been aware for more than a decade that these tires posed serious safety risks. Internal communications showed that the distributor had even warned dealers that such tires could make vehicles dangerously unstable and increase the likelihood of rollover accidents. Despite these warnings, the manufacturer stamped the tires with a maximum inflation recommendation of 45 psi—about 50% higher than the Tire and Rim Association guidelines for that size and type of tire. At this excessive pressure, a rupture was almost inevitable.
On the day of the crash, one of the oversized tires suffered a catastrophic blowout. The driver of the Blazer lost control, crossed the median, and collided head-on with the plaintiffs’ Ford Pinto. The mother was pinned inside the mangled car, suffering multiple injuries and drifting in and out of consciousness. Her daughter, strapped into the passenger seat, sustained fatal injuries and died two days later in the hospital.
The Legal and Moral Implications
The horror of this case extends beyond the loss of an innocent child. The deeper tragedy lies in the fact that the defendants knew this type of accident was foreseeable—and failed to take any effective action to prevent it. This inaction underscores a recurring problem in the automotive industry: when profit and expediency take precedence over public safety, the consequences can be deadly.
In defective tire cases, liability may extend beyond the manufacturer to include distributors, retailers, and even installers—particularly when there is documented knowledge of safety risks. In this case, the combination of improper product design, misleading inflation recommendations, and the failure to recall or remove dangerous products from the market was enough for the court to hold multiple parties accountable.
Common Causes of Tire Defects
- Design flaws – Poor engineering that makes a tire prone to failure under normal driving conditions.
- Manufacturing defects – Issues such as weak bonding, air pockets, or poor-quality materials during production.
- Improper labeling – Inaccurate inflation recommendations or misleading performance ratings.
- Failure to warn or recall – Knowledge of a hazard without adequate public notification or product recall.
Notable Tire Recalls
Large-scale tire recalls have occurred in recent decades, including the recall of 6.5 million Firestone ATX and Wilderness AT tires in the early 2000s. These recalls spurred a wave of litigation, as injured drivers and families of victims sought compensation for accidents caused by tire failures.
The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) maintains a public database of tire recalls, investigations, and safety bulletins. Consumers can use this resource to check whether their tires are affected by known defects.
What to Do if You Suspect a Tire Defect
- Preserve the tire – Do not discard the damaged tire; it is crucial evidence in any potential case.
- Document the scene – Take photographs of the vehicle, the tire, and any skid marks or debris.
- Seek medical attention – Even minor symptoms can indicate serious injuries.
- Report the defect – File a report with NHTSA to contribute to safety tracking and possible recalls.
- Consult an attorney – An experienced product liability lawyer can help investigate the cause and identify all responsible parties.
Seeking Justice
If you lose a family member or suffer injuries due to a defective tire, it is vital to seek legal representation promptly. Product liability and wrongful death cases involving defective automotive components require thorough investigation, expert testimony, and aggressive advocacy. Holding manufacturers, distributors, and retailers accountable not only secures justice for victims but also pressures the industry to improve safety standards and prevent future tragedies.
Contact a qualified defective product attorney to discuss your legal options and protect your rights. Your actions could help ensure that no other family has to endure the same preventable loss.
Related Reading
Free Consultation — No Fees Unless We Win
If you or a loved one was injured due to a suspected tire defect, our team can help investigate, preserve critical evidence, and pursue maximum compensation.
- ✅ Free, confidential case review
- ✅ We advance case costs
- ✅ No attorney’s fees unless we recover for you
📞 Call now:
(310) 724-6222 — Los Angeles
(415) 629-0109 — San Francisco
Or contact us online.
Disclaimer: This content is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Please consult with a licensed attorney regarding your specific situation.